Conducting Reliable Keyword Estimation with Unreliable ASR in Police Audio Data

Abstract

Extracting insights from large audio data sets using human transcription is expensive and time-consuming. Off-the-shelf Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems offer an easy-to-use scalable alternative, but systematic transcription errors, especially in domain-specific settings, can bias downstream analyses and lead to unreliable conclusions. We investigate whether imperfect ASR transcripts can still be used to obtain statistically valid keyword frequency estimates by combining model outputs with a small set of human-labeled examples, following Prediction Powered Inference and Design-based Supervised Learning frameworks. We evaluate this approach on police radio communications from Baltimore and Chicago, a domain in which keyword distributions could provide valuable insights into police activity, but off-the-shelf ASR systems exhibit systematic errors on operationally important terminology. Using bootstrap-based confidence interval coverage as our evaluation metric, we find that our approach substantially increases the number of domain-specific keywords that can be analyzed with statistically valid confidence intervals, from 43.0% using ASR alone and 27.2% using only a small set of human-labeled transcriptions to 56.2% in the Baltimore dataset, with similar improvements observed in Chicago data. Our results demonstrate that post-hoc error correction can improve statistical validity of downstream analyses even for poor-quality transcriptions, offering an avenue for better leveraging off-the-shelf ASR models for large-scale speech analysis.

The authors’ abstract, as arXiv lists it. arXiv’s listings, abstracts included, are free for anyone to reuse.

More in Computation & Language / NLP

• arXiv preprint · 19 October 2026

  Cognitive Maps in Large Language Models

  Albert Qin, Jonathan Cohen and Gautam Reddy
• arXiv preprint · 20 October 2026

  The Router Already Knows

  Andrew Bistras and Marty Johnson
• arXiv preprint · 19 October 2026

  Text Dominance in Paralinguistic Conflict: Tracing Suppression Through Audio LLM Circuits

  Ankur Banerjee, Vishnu Guntakala, Danity Pike and 3 others
• arXiv preprint · 20 October 2026

  Harness Self-Evolution for Long-Horizon Terminal Agents

  Ruhan Wang, Yucheng Shi, Zongxia Li and 6 others
• arXiv preprint · 19 October 2026

  Curriculum Learning Teaches LLMs Long-Horizon Implicit Reasoning, Up To A Limit

  Jimson Huang, Maxwell Nickell, Ruowang Zhang and 1 other

All new papers in Computation & Language / NLP