Beyond Reward Hacking: Proxy Divergence Across Four Layers of a Staged Humanoid Learning Pipeline

Abstract

A reinforcement-learning (RL) pipeline for a legged robot is assembled from proxies. A reward stands in for intended behaviour, a curriculum gate stands in for competence, an evaluation statistic stands in for robustness, and a reference motion stands in for an achievable skill. The traditional view treats only the first of these as optimised against, and so locates specification failure (reward hacking) in the reward alone. I argue that all four are proxies in the same formal sense, that each has a characteristic divergence mechanism, and that each admits a reformulation that closes it. For every layer I state the traditional formulation, derive the condition under which it diverges from its target, and give the alternative: first-order (L1) costs where quadratic kernels are flat, peak and outcome statistics where curriculum gates average, gate reachability and information checks, deterministic and phase-desynchronised evaluation, curriculum state treated as part of the model, feasibility-first reference design with residual feed-forward, and function-preserving input widening that lets one policy grow instead of being retrained. The arguments are illustrated by measurements from one continuous lineage of a PPO policy for a simulated 1.91 m humanoid, grown over four stages and 13,500 iterations on a single laptop GPU. Among them, a curriculum gate built on averaged error advanced at its rate limit on every check while the skill it gated was absent, and a batched push test whose synchronised resets aliased the gait phase ranked a 0.5 m/s push as more dangerous than a 2.0 m/s one.

The authors’ abstract, as arXiv lists it. arXiv’s listings, abstracts included, are free for anyone to reuse.

More in Robotics

• arXiv preprint · 2 October 2026

  Mind the Refinement Gap: When Safe High-Level Robot Plans Produce Unsafe Executions

  Stabak Das, Priyesh Ranjan, Xiangfang Li and 1 other
• arXiv preprint · 3 October 2026

  Autoware in Construction: Gap Analysis and LiDAR Perception Toward Off-Road Autonomous Driving

  Yu Otsuki, Teja Emmey, Sena Matsushita and 2 others
• arXiv preprint · 2 October 2026

  A Passive AI System for Verifying Physical State on Automated Liquid Handlers

  Junqiong Joanne Qiu, Zeckria Kamrany, Ananya Anand and 7 others
• arXiv preprint · 3 October 2026

  CurveCodec 2: Skeleton-agnostic animation compression with a learned entropy model

  Mingyi Shi, Huancheng Lin, Xuelin Chen and 1 other
• arXiv preprint · 2 October 2026

  DeltaWorld: Physically Consistent Interactive World Simulators via Action-Conditioned Latent Increment Learning

  Boyuan Hou, Xiaoge Cao, Chaofan Zhang and 2 others

All new papers in Robotics